Coin Center Donor Drop allocations

PGF Ops Proposal 🗳️
1

Hello! :wave: I’m writing this on behalf of Luminara :low_brightness:
We launched Namada Prop2, and are grateful that voters signalled strong support for our proposed Donor Drop that targeted the amazing Coin Center team:

Now the Donor Drop is complete :tada: Many thanks to the many different kinds of participants :raised_hands:

This is a PGF (public goods funding) proposal to distribute 1,225,986 NAM to the 188 Namada addresses listed here.
This proposal has been tested and successfully executed on the Housefire testnet: https://namada-explorer.sproutstake.space/test/proposals/6.

The aim was to award 1m NAM, the lower boundary of this draft proposal, but we are instead asking you to approve this proposal to distribute ~1.226m NAM. This is to reward donors whose donations were not reported during the Donor Drop tally, due to issues such as invalid/missing tnam addresses.

There are plausible reasons for why this happened, and we now have some learnings, and we’d still like to thank and welcome these participants to our community. Please see details here: Donor Drop - coincenter.eth - Google Sheets

Note:

  1. We’ve provided evidence for all corrected addresses with the exception of two, highlighted in red at the top of the spreadsheet. We’d like to give them the benefit of the doubt and reward them regardless. There were no competing claims on these two donations, totalling 6,666 NAM.

  2. There were four donations that attempted to participate but arrived some time after the Donor Drop ended. We are not asking that they be included in this proposal, and instead, I personally would like to thank and reward them once transfers are enabled in Phase 5.

    image
    image1828×350 36.3 KB

History

Shortly after Prop2 passed, at least seven Namada community members independently and collaboratively got involved at different times and in different ways on a few potential Donor Drop app solutions. It was an incredible grassroots initiative in support of our first Donor Drop, with dedication that far exceeded my expectations :fire:

When the Donor Drop window opened on Saturday, January 18, Coin Center’s ethereum address received nearly 200 donations in about 35 minutes, totalling 36.78 ETH, worth about $125k when the Donor Drop finished :eyes:

This will be a testament to Namada’s novel technology, and we hope that others will use and improve upon the Donor Drop distribution mechanism & strategy. Please check out this forum post for the full summary of this campaign:

11 Likes
2

All makes sense to me! Thanks to you, Luminara, and everyone else involved in the Donor Drop for amazing execution and meticulous accounting! I hope and expect that this will inspire similar initiatives in the future.

6 Likes
3

We anticipate launching this PGF proposal as soon as the v1.1.1 mainnet upgrade is complete, in ~69 hours from now: https://explorer75.org/namada/blocks/894000

image
image1412×792 59 KB

4 Likes
4

Mandragora will be supporting the proposal.

1 Like
5

This proposal is live: https://namada-explorer.sproutstake.space/main/proposals/5

Here are the contents of the json file from the proposal:

{
  "proposal": {
    "content": {
      "title": "PGF - Coin Center Donor Drop allocations",
      "authors": "Gavin Birch (Luminara)",
      "discussions-to": "https://forum.namada.net/t/coin-center-donor-drop-allocations/1508",
      "created": "2025-02-12",
      "abstract": "PGF proposal to distribute 1,225,986 NAM in total to the 188 addresses that donated to Coin Center",

character limit reached, to be continued in next post…

1 Like
6

continued from Coin Center Donor Drop allocations - #5 by Gavin

      "motivation": "(see abstract)",
      "details": "This is a PGF (public goods funding) proposal to distribute a total of 1,225,986 NAM to the 188 Namada addresses listed here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1uMGqq1BtPlNP25DnCGmkw78DFFEW2le9BG0GgfueRAI/edit?gid=764951800&range=F2.\nThis proposal has been tested and successfully executed on the Housefire testnet: https://namada-explorer.sproutstake.space/test/proposals/6\n\n## Context\nGavin Birch has launched this proposal on behalf of Luminara 🔅\n\nWe previously launched Namada Prop2, and are grateful that voters signalled strong support for our proposed Donor Drop that targeted the amazing Coin Center team: https://forum.namada.net/t/draft-signalling-proposal-will-you-support-an-airdrop-campaign-using-namadas-pgf/1338\n\nThe Donor Drop is done, 🎉 many thanks to the many different kinds of participants 🙌\n\n## Details\nThe aim was to award 1m NAM, the lower boundary of this draft proposal: https://forum.namada.net/t/draft-signalling-proposal-will-you-support-an-airdrop-campaign-using-namadas-pgf/1338, but we are instead asking you to approve this proposal to distribute ~1.226m NAM. This is to reward donors whose donations were not reported during the Donor Drop tally, due to issues such as invalid/missing tnam addresses.\n\nThere are plausible reasons for why this happened, and we now have some learnings, and we'd still like to thank and welcome these participants to our community. Please see details here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1uMGqq1BtPlNP25DnCGmkw78DFFEW2le9BG0GgfueRAI/edit?gid=1986442751&range=A1\n\n**Note:**\n1. We've provided evidence for all corrected addresses with the exception of two, highlighted in red at the top of the spreadsheet. We'd like to give them the benefit of the doubt and reward them regardless. There were no competing claims on these two donations, totalling 6,666 NAM.\n\n2. There were four donations that attempted to participate but arrived some time after the Donor Drop ended. We are not asking that they be included in this proposal, and instead, I personally would like to thank and reward them once transfers are enabled in Phase 5.\n\n## History\nShortly after Prop2 passed, at least seven Namada community members independently and collaboratively got involved at different times and in different ways on a few potential Donor Drop app solutions. It was an incredible grassroots initiative in support of our first Donor Drop, with dedication that far exceeded my expectations 🔥\n\nWhen the Donor Drop window opened on Saturday, January 18, Coin Center’s ethereum address received nearly 200 donations in about 35 minutes, totalling 36.78 ETH, worth about $125k when the Donor Drop finished 👀\n\n## Mooaar Donor Drops\nThis will be a testament to Namada's novel technology, and we hope that others will use and improve upon the Donor Drop distribution mechanism & strategy. Please check out this forum post for the full summary of this campaign: https://forum.namada.net/t/donor-drop-success-36-78-eth-donated-to-coin-center/1492",
      "requires": "0"
    },
    "author": "tnam1qztdx4y7a3wn0qmgcgtrty237vcnp9f9hs3rt3k7",
    "voting_start_epoch": 288,
    "voting_end_epoch": 300,
    "activation_epoch": 301
  },
  "data": {
    "continuous": [],
    "retro": [
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qp4d57kez3s2py6e5z5mc4cxjqj3ytpzqqrm5jsc"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzdnlmyj6ce7dle98pnjdtv4vth4a075hy08w7d3"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqvxtelzpyqrhljtrvpgt895jaxcawtclsf35yla"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "6000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrln4wg6utlya4redwxrpzut3h35z9h0t5hxffct"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzykeachafh86cxvxmm6z5nsp0jrukjmwgue6d67"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qp9q4ny744pwr4pl8d0rzu0ggreghr59cg4tt9g9"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "5600000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz6pkx7xjvwu2lymcazgspl4807ysfmlfunedvwu"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "6667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrndwqtmgyavuh6es5yly9lkh9kllh8twcct9qr0"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qq03yaxus9w60g7gmejck3raz4ccd3ataqfy8hgy"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrlp94hx0k9h5k092lld0qd058tmgluzcqgw5609"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpu00p4qkv75fdqqjpq8yljt2w2vgwrs8vv9568f"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrg4za3wm588fjg5fe7tcfx6ws2mvahvqccr5457"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qph489h92n32qggkfh8t5ml308nezelx355s8v4h"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpcufwv5gchucxandrpxl36s5yzl6qmz85uy9ps9"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz706393ts56nk0n64maf2f4j557e6kjusmvqq9w"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1033000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqzadxft4m9e2zettg4y9f6rr9zpl92arvwsklvw"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzt6r9lm7rglz3zdewtkzyctmgd4yfp0c5u3gs6d"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "6667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpyls0r0n3vzrjeqwzjfqjvvpqqwz479puzg9vms"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqyvfvgvw67y2vxskah2l0837v2wu5q94q22rgw7"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "4000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqj2qrtxjv84gst9y7ag7kzan6fp9k8fvv2yamqz"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqdljdqyj0m2h5ryudcg9g3jkpese2474yt0gdsl"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzcf06ctstz62cjdk8t2dej2xms9vqf8xgacuf9c"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qp000p5mcvxzeky63t9cusmhmj0p4jr67gzfjhsk"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpa5mhgp8s8c7c3n45pvlqgrauculj6z8ca54nth"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qruj8gq2gre433gx307d9aldyctqh65pls4rud4x"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqhkxrpkmpj3xuf246ktdm8jy7vu4ut8tgn4jpt3"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzsey3axv20hhkkc0rf9hx4d4vps665r0y729kt6"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "8333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qq3ah2gy356dkattasm84ylwk7sk2v38h5ks7ttn"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qry2knysd74ht7yyfrvpjcctehrvv2est5cy7wqe"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqrh0czvjcade0a7tyq682sms4dt0axvxgd7m7lg"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qry8tghqlh6ys2jvcatp79vsny3gjf0ukyup94fz"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qr973rs46uy462lrl4skdp7ss2us40m5jyxk6n7j"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "6600000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrzhjhvaldhguz4yncxfudldaed6s5eq8yn4jfxu"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "9667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpap42lc78zpnr7dupqc49gfvghw8z93tgv5ddas"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qru5k3dcckk5f00usqlct753q0rmzrwvrq94u7ky"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qq2vfp0u0rmmqn8hmfz6ype4cfj2757r9yfryjcn"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrllankes8t3nqg7kjfvwzdmyuq6dm94kukwm3fl"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzphyvtqe0ax2z5va4ywe7qhgutw7kclfgttmr84"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzp9tp2ssaq6u0r9nw6ytzvew3wamwtz0cllhsg4"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrll6jlru2kk3tltekwu63qyde83hhdyngd0vxfp"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrh7rmgh8xgjxwpck9q4x6r5r2zxwglllsmqqy66"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1033000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzk0qcg5jzdlar890js3wvpp8tjq6aglucq3l497"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzaqru2gj0r3u2yuw6ma8cnvwxn6nu4nmu8c4fmq"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzpwlnpj0x26ltau6r9g7036hqaj0vvpqup2ynmd"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqcvczfsdgftp4c3cwtm46wkjgnzh5v0scmn0lgx"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qq4vk6q5yuhvawdu8yqswmhn7elcxemk5v5pfjay"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1533000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpcfk5l6reajc0nzkjy953d7npyshz44nygr5t5w"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "9667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrleyuc6f72vwhc03kevlykag60hdh26zs3dpk6h"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1167000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzpry3mmf6p2qv2seyzav76v9tgcxgcj5smdhwd8"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qq38jr63jrgp7a0g2nulx6zhxx90pcqadvwrf2t5"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qr4upllgy49ssgskxg94ynxux00fy36fdulmvljm"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrlck4dyh4028edjz85vlkr6efzjlsvwlq2x7y5m"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpwvgxjv73mx93qeqlxyzltd5058d9r3uugeh6wd"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "2933000000",
          "target": "tnam1qp72d9aq5kgqflvwlw439sq06upyl0mtnv2mrfw8"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrlcnxet5e8a9rwmzzsh74qcnz7a5tmm2uuszxwq"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qplk07jgsu3n9cdud6f2htqg6vnxyykmdycrhg3p"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpnn5lsrvu2agy20k0mradndtkmzpktxwcny6p5c"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqua5st3mh0j6zrt3plsp27wh28203trnyfasvt5"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrcf8xs66299k5jc8xe6asw4hl2tqw6kwse66hlk"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrdlgvhmz8jpreu725fp755yvkrnff3fhgqrprrc"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpsf8s0frysmskyccghudssh7d0a2tsdxydpwc9e"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qp0rurv660wq07628wswr4p4hdghru28zgnx0vj8"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz270z5r89atrc34zz9p0x6qymak5pedwqwh0jpy"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrlhdfakd0pcrahcfe5r9vdyh7s2c8499ymhm8l9"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "8333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qr5r3c939mukgy9sngar93ytq4ttp0gctyjs7k4u"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "8333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrlkf0pwnup48tllmzq95t6kdajgkg4s9g9yuhav"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "9333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpur87kyc8fcuq8mufg80ex96y9h8e9lfvg533kh"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpsjzwzmhreqdknp5ez2s7g4gjph6q6gdswl76mk"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzh0kj42ynyqlrmarekyruyy0m02smch05gwmp9w"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qq0me5xeczkfww2c0gpz3ea7up07ftj8lgv4wks0"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1500000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqu586c9t90jrt7lkjcld6zhs2dj23vzlgw2fc5g"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrmnfcvp2h3nf0q0lqc8a9227l6n5x0psqjr8756"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qr5p88d28ahtkzzkthhfpj6czu4war7kxg3grfp6"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrl5vegnw7tssggugu5qt4r5dcyfq6ptqgytgueg"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzdytu26mqmd86t9kkyqky52pcanveuzcumktaj8"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzm842hyn8ya3hhcpld6qnp8a5vw3nfp9uuzjz2y"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "9667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqzc4ljfgj4t2dsky4l5w2mqkvuqkmh0hc60g4m8"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "9833000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrls3l7a39lasd92dy7pwuapr2xq79dtw5uwz5zg"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1433000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqwlsrjd2vmqj4m5x8682thx5frmezpuussk3ef0"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpfgxx3zumfnrsww4lh6kghwa625vv0zncxv6qte"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qp3v68sgv4c7vsdkmvjupklg5v8chwaqhy7yhplt"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3246000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpmnmc26gjya2aavndqc9m8rqlf536ngfvaavulc"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "9333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqtcmluwrd9xuer5ws62gna70hhe3q5whg8d5sc9"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpj0642qewpw48le37jx2rw7ff80y8ynzq8y43vq"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrxlse6r56e97h285hfme38ytetlpg9hjq56xhrv"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpuuchxsgf44kcjre9mwf7kxppj7jay5sq8y34xs"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrl0nzqhrdku9r03mvq6qn9cy56th92lsv4a22su"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qr3uffvc28rkytlf0pd7llxua45h7g6xxslmqym5"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qplf7pqk0ca8x9avz8et5lmqa9ujkhqspv0f6ke7"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1067000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzjz2vwfxd8wnjfktl0mcnwxd3q48jmfz5mz8lmy"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "8338000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpexmegxm22ac7y7mvdel2rv7equ6mz9rg4tn475"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzz668tdgy2nrtvq8rv5509mhs5zxl3f3gyrluth"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpyhcq0ccs84l5fcydm6xtnvkjwwteeu3vawff9k"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqlvmfnlm99pf3at525knde5e57yy750xchfe7jc"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qp6cy3yc4mep2fapu7rma2fks0w9n94js5rtrnsa"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqp8p54kdrrneap4ees5kzv3qyanfwpglclt7c2p"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqgczxf4tkvvqwwtra876jwuh679avylesdywqgf"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qre4gda5s46k629jqmdqdjr8a2rznfx8l5zvmajj"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1067000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrc0q08nvmhlne2cjehjshjk54yn926avv40tt3n"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz4em2jlylp5aflr3mm2j48jvj5v9aegnv7nqfr7"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "9233000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpmptdcwjzr0cudmu8zs3gdfew5ek4cgqckjwq7a"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1767000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpclwg3qe23m05xqqxz3t52wc7n6ahfq0ucaq6sn"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpwgazahdqf2turm6edeqrzyyyg4h7p3j526fqsd"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "4000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz8munn3zjzjlsr6k24w59s29dgx94l0au63dlnc"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqaejsxku0tyyxg2gp9yw3w003fqjha75qme5k7j"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrcjqujm3pwfu809lfs70703da7u56qk2vkfj4mg"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpxxqfue624a53w7dl8zcknres5lg6vgagreh3c0"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "6667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzkx2k6zxjcdxf5tz4ep55mj4ll2kq7wsyrd5k5u"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1033000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpgnhumlpp6fwculxz8cgr24a7usqm4hnv0axzp8"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz36fzmkrjpgf8mwrj97sd53v28zqtp8u5j9xe7l"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzjma7da4vnrdrxv8tegpc6vh9rdy4mqj5wlczqs"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz2dmyplq5t6plvzavr4vu48e3d9tpu0dvwazyyx"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqzdgxpgfr7zusqmmsxqlplp3hn0m6f2uyfrlrfl"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1033000000",
          "target": "tnam1qruzkhq4sctz7pce6y63jcn7phtf7dqp3gdggk83"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1067000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrf33fdtw9y47a8nfy0thv48mhsysd883c86fjjr"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzlh47mcne4d5h205ucyf3t5y4hzrekg6czvq6u3"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "9667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qp2etn7qwq94lxkh7qcu3g9h2e5pe3pqwyehxfcu"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqgdqtmk6ceje9vft8dd327cvs0dzrxe8clzshdc"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrcdeupx8m83uamty97kdqmgn650qkq86583sd8e"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "6667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpck8s8akl4facfacucntmzynvkhjd4enqcqs6mp"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrqxf84jgfmcd5e088zwhk2a0lndmp5a9udm8hzw"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqh84yxh64f95mtue3axum2y6359tgra4ym7wag6"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqw7g9pxmhrjnxaxr8ry6g3esxkhm2ynvyjah577"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrjh69407d9kl0yfg5g7zkcn6a7kjckhcgpummyl"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrlrgy2pqn4mkkqx8mucfwxzz7hrk2vz9v3qjlmk"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "7543000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzkvtp6mmfseefjwgtaaw2zwl92qcf9c8s58rxdu"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qznu3rr9scxqxj884ae0v369hejr9m792yt70cag"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qq3el64jh9f8jcltrwuw3dr09jxqyqhzvgyh3yzl"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qql5swl4fzzpe37aulnq99jxq68dyz2l9vz2n3fh"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "2033000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz2tvjselhkls5ky24rk4uafjmymxw65h5e24k7d"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrveqtk8vhyd9tztqfpy5859ef4pr0mpas2a3r7l"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrg4ymhfu6wlpaxwywkxmd6kuvc2zls48ugtd0a3"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzrpvc2jqcpl4ud7xccgncgvux7y5f9nvc0tdw3k"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz2qjwzlnzqz3upt9m2vjjqhn85ctxgevynkavzf"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "4000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpzaz45jsx6wqm2230xfrkwnqvq9sdukwcqm0mg9"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzgqw0qunv28tm0yr32hr3khwel92ljgquas3zv3"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "6667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz98ev8zqwedhk9426n5tp4zqm6ax26jeclvwuw2"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrx9lcv7ehjdupy60rct4jkxlwuxdjk5mchhlf36"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzu5njshjtxddqve2aummlhx28uvh7nkdv5zthfd"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzdczcxjvs5a2nk4nr2m34c0zdatcjdq0q52wdw3"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzyh8z5vk2ngye5uucnr9ptdelv8ywnxhgula2sg"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzsvz5hpegks96amhvm73x79xqk6mwdf6gpwzkh8"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpgz0tfs7hk3v2pru8gc2766g2u7pj307uk7xfu3"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qq37cjdtkpnwefg2fhx6eays34r48yc5nyz0chjq"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz5d2php5wwqaw806uzmwpv386lg0yvdrgna4ens"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzwlmt5yh80tx2zzfq2pvlex6qel9pzk3sj875v2"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrc22vellpse9kn2f486qapdjgauez2gdy0ycfe6"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1631000000",
          "target": "tnam1qp9rghx7nzvx4luc5guyvmaszkgtpsqgp5prha2z"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpncjnu3dqr9p6jnftra84r87lh6vu33tgnwrplh"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzh0kj42ynyqlrmarekyruyy0m02smch05gwmp9w"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqw7g9pxmhrjnxaxr8ry6g3esxkhm2ynvyjah577"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzgklpcldvpw7xda4xsdtch39wtvq8t9kgzap3l7"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzljs9rtn0h52hqr7ll8kqtvhljx6j9e2vplk44g"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "9667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qr8hwhdk2rluj6j0lups5ud2wmp93k0vyuuuhk7j"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzkx2k6zxjcdxf5tz4ep55mj4ll2kq7wsyrd5k5u"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz98ev8zqwedhk9426n5tp4zqm6ax26jeclvwuw2"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qr3wun8geungddhhv2rn0twaw25wvuw4ayttesd7"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzkx2k6zxjcdxf5tz4ep55mj4ll2kq7wsyrd5k5u"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "2000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzvtd2uyzngqa0pxfp82azp4yljv79nfysvmmhu5"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qquuqejec7hj258dyg64shl6rj3lcvkgyy6ejlyw"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrtppdaxdfnrajquk5drq95mcct3ya3k3crfdsx2"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzvlqa26fzw3yn5l68t5nj7kvw9g3gj7cv489nl3"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzt6cwy0s9l2suzjyt77j55tz834jlmkzgjmh662"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qphkhqqxj6zfp32y7f8jfnxeardm0ywftg3np9ux"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzlgna0v3fhtzapnaqh0qn9c5ywjuzmzayfu5jx4"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpwssr8725y59qk0vaney5wvs2zvzsx4mgnpgw7e"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qr8u9wgncc70vqa2c328lyakfj3lrsl98yste2qg"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpcnayymes30guakfmxtgj46g6azjtcqmvl9yadn"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1033000000",
          "target": "tnam1qz9dnsq2k25qfrk3jvzk80fdmamw2xme4583tydh"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzd3u8eev33lmntgspyc0slh3ajy7unwa59mvxn5"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzj8s4keg9y9wtl6tvwunzkzdyvnemzaecjdtn5e"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpvz9n4df8s603dy3hcnzj9qtndteufxav3f2m42"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qr3kx7wuze2ywx2n3u9dpfxt7dct6n3fxcavu755"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1833000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzuj7hcysudy29jkzdg2zv4zvmfptapafsfmcn2w"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpg9nt2q8mk832r4rc674h990ya5vpeu3up2rhsj"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qztj7nnw2wvff49gpe330warrfx5gvw6gga5up0w"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "2000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqq0q2z8xjqjvz8zdvaldsklkx9tmaagu54jng79"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qztj7nnw2wvff49gpe330warrfx5gvw6gga5up0w"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "10000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qqnwn6tqa36ljf3t5ajy5xu9ymevt8a28sx2rkjh"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzsx7y0cg2q4hguprups7fnh05txjaywmshggu0g"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpqn26nvzm5p3av9m3pz8qg5urx9wesvgu5q9dr4"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "5000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrj0luufnu8gm5nxcs53j93cvrk3mnp8tyrrcgqz"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "5000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qr3axn6sdux6cs663dcx75cuh7gqeyacsssamss0"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qphkhqqxj6zfp32y7f8jfnxeardm0ywftg3np9ux"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1000000000",
          "target": "tnam1qq9xcccepwfy6agslnj74k3f9589h2c4esupth6y"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "4064000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrs3dldqqujrk0gc9nm8ddywje7vqv25my28vzty"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qpzgm7yxty5w7z0svrtwljm9swahn2qm5vmwqtcs"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qrtz2lynljnz329e4lx4vu2x4shwwn3rgvenldqj"
        }
      }
    ]
  }
}
7

I have voted nay because of 2 duplicate entries that have been filtered out. May change to yay if there is a fix for them.

1 Like
8

Two addresses will not receive the intended PGF amount, because of an interesting phenomenon: if the PGF proposal contains more than one entry for the same address and the same number of NAM, only one of the entries is actually enacted.

image
image1464×390 63.3 KB

Additionally, one of the duplicates was not intentional–it was supposed to be a different tnam address, and so it’s good that this won’t be enacted. To rectify the situation, I’ve prepared a new PGF proposal to accompany the first.

HUGE thanks to :sparkles: @zenodeapp and @Rigorous :sparkles: for reporting the issue and the cause :star_struck:

2 Likes
9

Changed vote to yay and looking forward to the fix in proposal 6.

2 Likes
10

Prop6 voting has begun :ballot_box:

PGF Prop6, the proposal to distribute total of 5,000 NAM missing from PGF Prop5, is now live and voting: https://explorer75.org/namada/proposals/6

Thanks to Zen & Rigorous for reviewing :raised_hands:

json attachment

{
  "proposal": {
    "content": {
      "title": "PGF - accompanying fix for Donor Drop Prop5",
      "authors": "Gavin Birch (Luminara 🔅)",
      "discussions-to": "https://forum.namada.net/t/coin-center-donor-drop-allocations/1508/8",
      "created": "2025-02-14",
      "abstract": "PGF proposal to distribute total of 5,000 NAM missing from PGF Prop5",
      "motivation": "(see abstract)",
      "details": "This is a PGF (public goods funding) proposal to distribute a total of 5,000 NAM to these two Namada addresses:\n1) tnam1qzkx2k6zxjcdxf5tz4ep55mj4ll2kq7wsyrd5k5u - 1,667 NAM\n2) tnam1qr649fhvu3f3mdaxs80mm7gsm5uyegsv4g596flz - 3,333 NAM\nIt won't be valid unless Prop5 is also approved.\n\n## Context\nGavin Birch has launched this proposal on behalf of Luminara 🔅\nWe also launched Namada Prop5: https://explorer75.org/namada/proposals/5\nHowever, if Prop5 is approved, two addresses will not receive their intended totals because of an interesting phenomenon: if the PGF proposal contains more than one entry for the same address *and* the same number of NAM, only one of the entries is actually enacted. Prop5 intentionally had one duplicate entry, which the protocol is ignoring, and the other duplicate is the incorrect tnam address (corrected in this proposal). It's a unique set of circumstances (ie. transfers disabled) that we ask you to approve this relatively small PGF proposal as a solution to the problem that arose from this issue: https://github.com/anoma/namada/issues/4380\n\n## Future\nWe recommend summing a total for each address in future, instead of multiple entries for the same address. Additionally, the duplication error could have been discovered with more thorough data analysis of the Housefire test proposal. Huge thanks to Zen 🦸 and Rigorous 🦸 for discovering and reporting this!",
      "requires": "5"
    },
    "author": "tnam1qztdx4y7a3wn0qmgcgtrty237vcnp9f9hs3rt3k7",
    "voting_start_epoch": 296,
    "voting_end_epoch": 308,
    "activation_epoch": 309
  },
  "data": {
    "continuous": [],
    "retro": [
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "1667000000",
          "target": "tnam1qzkx2k6zxjcdxf5tz4ep55mj4ll2kq7wsyrd5k5u"
        }
      },
      {
        "Internal": {
          "amount": "3333000000",
          "target": "tnam1qr649fhvu3f3mdaxs80mm7gsm5uyegsv4g596flz"
        }
      }
    ]
  }
}
3 Likes
11

These proposals successfully executed :white_check_mark:

Thanks to all the voters for your confidence! :heart:

1 Like
12

This topic was automatically closed after 40 hours. New replies are no longer allowed.